Rolling Stone's Massive Disservice to Rape Survivors
by
Jess
- Thursday, December 11, 2014
We're going to go a bit off the normal topics that I blog about here and tackle something a little more serious because I have a lot of thoughts and feelings on this Rolling Stone/U-Va. cluster-F.
Some background before we dive into this:
I'm a journalist by trade, and though I don't work in a newsroom practicing the craft on a daily basis anymore, I still put a lot of weight in the basic tenants of journalism.
I have the utmost respect for the reporters who are out there every day chasing stories, tracking down leads, talking to uncooperative witnesses to keep the rest of us in the loop on what's going on in the world.
It's why I teach a college-level intro to reporting class to aspiring reporters (though I'm on a hiatus now because of grad school).
But, I also have some pretty major personal biases when it comes to this story, so I'm going to put them out there because I know they color my opinion on this whole thing. In no way do I claim to be unbiased about any of this.
When I was in high school and college, two people I am very close to were raped at Maryland.
I will never, ever forget the shock, horror and complete terror I felt when I first found out.
As a result, I didn't drink during my first three years of college. I can count the number of frat parties I went to on one hand, and heaven knows I never touched the Jungle Juice (Lord only knows what they threw in that stuff.) I was the kid who made sure all her friends got home safely from said parties, no matter how much they drank.
In the Greek system, I believe that was the role played by the "sober sister." In my world, it was just being a good friend.
As a result of all this, I will also 110% always, always believe the survivor.
So on that basic, human level, I understand why the Rolling Stone reporter and the many editors and legal people who reviewed the piece believed Jackie's story. It's very, very hard to imagine someone would make up something that traumatic.
But that Rolling Stone reporter and all those editors had a journalistic responsibility to fact check every single element of that story. They don't get to just accept a source at her word, especially not in a case like this.
I don't care that Jackie asked them to not talk to anyone about it. If as a news organization, you're going to run that story, you damn well better do your homework.
Because you know what happens now? Now people think Jackie's a liar and maybe the whole thing is made up, and maybe rape on college campuses isn't really that big of a deal, and this whole thing is getting overblown for no reason, because some overzealous reporter wanted to write a "gotcha" story.
And that, quite frankly, sucks. Because rape on college campuses is a problem.
It happens all too often, it's grossly underreported and when it is reported, it's often swept under the rug -- especially if the offender is a rich, privileged kid or (god-forbid for the university) a scholarship athlete.
I believe something happened to Jackie. I don't know what. I doubt it's exactly what Rolling Stone reported, but something happened to her. You don't go public with a story like that (even if your name is withheld) if it's completely false.
Somewhere in that story is a kernel of truth, and it was Rolling Stone's responsibility to ask more questions, to get at that exact story and to report on the facts that actually happened.
In journalism school, we teach fair and balanced reporting. That means giving all parties the opportunity to tell their side. As a reporter you don't get to pick and choose your sources so that it makes for a better story. You have to dig and dig until you talk to everyone. You never accept one person's story as the cold, hard facts -- even if that person is a rape survivor with a very powerful and convincing story.
So what Rolling Stone did was a majorly epic journalism fail. The gross irresponsibility in reporting truly blows my mind.
And while my heart breaks for Jackie that she experienced any sort of trauma, I can't help but be a little frustrated with the inconsistencies in her story.
Rape and sexual assault on college campuses are such a massive issues that desperately need to be addressed. But it's hard to hold this up as an example of why that's the case when it's so easy to punch holes in Jackie's story with even a little bit of digging and fact checking.
Jackie's story certainly called attention to the issue, but now it's too easy for people to brush it off as a bunch of lies, half-truths or fabrications. And that does a massive disservice to anyone who is brave enough to report this kind of crime in the future.
Some background before we dive into this:
I'm a journalist by trade, and though I don't work in a newsroom practicing the craft on a daily basis anymore, I still put a lot of weight in the basic tenants of journalism.
I have the utmost respect for the reporters who are out there every day chasing stories, tracking down leads, talking to uncooperative witnesses to keep the rest of us in the loop on what's going on in the world.
It's why I teach a college-level intro to reporting class to aspiring reporters (though I'm on a hiatus now because of grad school).
But, I also have some pretty major personal biases when it comes to this story, so I'm going to put them out there because I know they color my opinion on this whole thing. In no way do I claim to be unbiased about any of this.
When I was in high school and college, two people I am very close to were raped at Maryland.
I will never, ever forget the shock, horror and complete terror I felt when I first found out.
As a result, I didn't drink during my first three years of college. I can count the number of frat parties I went to on one hand, and heaven knows I never touched the Jungle Juice (Lord only knows what they threw in that stuff.) I was the kid who made sure all her friends got home safely from said parties, no matter how much they drank.
In the Greek system, I believe that was the role played by the "sober sister." In my world, it was just being a good friend.
As a result of all this, I will also 110% always, always believe the survivor.
So on that basic, human level, I understand why the Rolling Stone reporter and the many editors and legal people who reviewed the piece believed Jackie's story. It's very, very hard to imagine someone would make up something that traumatic.
But that Rolling Stone reporter and all those editors had a journalistic responsibility to fact check every single element of that story. They don't get to just accept a source at her word, especially not in a case like this.
I don't care that Jackie asked them to not talk to anyone about it. If as a news organization, you're going to run that story, you damn well better do your homework.
Because you know what happens now? Now people think Jackie's a liar and maybe the whole thing is made up, and maybe rape on college campuses isn't really that big of a deal, and this whole thing is getting overblown for no reason, because some overzealous reporter wanted to write a "gotcha" story.
And that, quite frankly, sucks. Because rape on college campuses is a problem.
It happens all too often, it's grossly underreported and when it is reported, it's often swept under the rug -- especially if the offender is a rich, privileged kid or (god-forbid for the university) a scholarship athlete.
I believe something happened to Jackie. I don't know what. I doubt it's exactly what Rolling Stone reported, but something happened to her. You don't go public with a story like that (even if your name is withheld) if it's completely false.
Somewhere in that story is a kernel of truth, and it was Rolling Stone's responsibility to ask more questions, to get at that exact story and to report on the facts that actually happened.
In journalism school, we teach fair and balanced reporting. That means giving all parties the opportunity to tell their side. As a reporter you don't get to pick and choose your sources so that it makes for a better story. You have to dig and dig until you talk to everyone. You never accept one person's story as the cold, hard facts -- even if that person is a rape survivor with a very powerful and convincing story.
So what Rolling Stone did was a majorly epic journalism fail. The gross irresponsibility in reporting truly blows my mind.
And while my heart breaks for Jackie that she experienced any sort of trauma, I can't help but be a little frustrated with the inconsistencies in her story.
Rape and sexual assault on college campuses are such a massive issues that desperately need to be addressed. But it's hard to hold this up as an example of why that's the case when it's so easy to punch holes in Jackie's story with even a little bit of digging and fact checking.
Jackie's story certainly called attention to the issue, but now it's too easy for people to brush it off as a bunch of lies, half-truths or fabrications. And that does a massive disservice to anyone who is brave enough to report this kind of crime in the future.















